The Difference Between Centrifugal and Positive Displacement Pumps

Centrifugal pumps operate on the principle of converting kinetic energy into hydrodynamic energy. The core component of a centrifugal pump is its impeller, which is a rotating device that accelerates the liquid. As the liquid enters the pump, it is drawn into the center of the impeller, which rapidly spins and pushes the liquid outwards due to centrifugal force. This action increases the liquid’s velocity, converting the mechanical energy of the impeller into the kinetic energy of the liquid. The pump’s casing then directs this high-speed fluid to the discharge point, converting velocity to pressure continuously as the fluid exits the pump. Here is a basic sequence of how a centrifugal pump operates:

1. Liquid enters the pump impeller along or near to the rotating axis.
2. The impeller spins the liquid outwards and increases its kinetic energy.
3. The liquid moves into the pump casing where its velocity is converted into pressure.
4. High-pressure liquid exits the pump.

In contrast, positive displacement pumps function by trapping a fixed amount of liquid and forcing it into the discharge pipe. Unlike centrifugal pumps, these pumps create flow through displacement and are known for their ability to handle viscous fluids and maintain a constant flow rate irrespective of the pressure conditions. There are several types of positive displacement pumps, including gear pumps, piston pumps, and diaphragm pumps, among others.

The working mechanism of positive displacement pumps can be summarized as:

• Trapping liquid: Fluid enters the pump and gets trapped between the moving parts.
• Displacement: The trapped volume of liquid is physically moved through the pump.
• Discharge: The moved volume of liquid is forced out into the discharge pipe.

Based on their mechanism, the operation of positive displacement pumps is typically characterized by pulsations in the flow, especially noticeable in single and double-acting reciprocating types. These pulsations occur because the liquid is released intermittently rather than in a continuous flow.

Here’s a simple comparison in

This structured elucidation not only clarifies the operational dynamics of each type of pump but also begins to hint at their applicability based on mechanical capabilities and limitations.

Key applications and selection criteria

Selecting the right pump is crucial for specific applications because it impacts system efficiency, maintenance frequency, cost, and overall performance. Understanding the key applications and selection criteria for both centrifugal and positive displacement pumps can guide engineers and operators in making an informed choice.

Centrifugal Pumps are predominantly used where high flow rates or high flow velocities are required. These pumps are ideal for applications involving low-viscosity liquids like water, solvents, and light oils. Typical uses include:

• Water supply systems
• Building services such as heating and air conditioning
• Irrigation and agriculture
• Chemical processing with non-viscous chemicals

In contrast, Positive Displacement Pumps excel in applications where accuracy, high pressure, and the ability to handle viscous fluids are paramount. They are suitably employed for:

• Oil and gas industries, particularly for pumping crude oil, mud, and slurry
• Chemical and pharmaceutical manufacturing, for handling viscous fluids and sensitive compounds that require precise dosing
• Food and beverage processing, where maintaining product integrity (like texture) is crucial
• Waste management, including sewage and sludge processing

When selecting between centrifugal and positive displacement pumps, the following criteria should be considered:

Understanding these selection criteria can significantly influence the performance and longevity of the pump in specific applications. Engineers must balance these considerations with cost and operational conditions to choose the most suitable pump for their needs.

Maintenance and efficiency comparison

Maintaining and ensuring the efficiency of pumps is critical for their long-term operation and cost-effectiveness. Both centrifugal and positive displacement pumps have distinct maintenance needs and efficiency characteristics, influenced by their design and operational environments.

Centrifugal Pumps: These pumps generally require less frequent maintenance compared to positive displacement pumps. This is primarily due to their simpler design, which has fewer moving parts (typically just the impeller and associated bearings). The main issues usually involve impeller wear, seal replacement, and bearing lubrication. Here are the typical maintenance actions for centrifugal pumps:

• Regular inspection and cleaning of the impeller to prevent clogging and efficiency loss.
• Monitoring and replacement of seals and bearings to prevent leaks and mechanical failures.
• Lubrication of bearings to ensure smooth operation and reduce wear.

Efficiency-wise, centrifugal pumps are more effective when operating with low-viscosity fluids at high flow rates. They exhibit reduced efficiency when handling high-viscosity fluids or in applications that demand high pressure, primarily due to slippage and increased frictional losses within the pump.

Positive Displacement Pumps: These pumps typically encounter more frequent and varied maintenance issues due to their complex mechanisms (such as gears, pistons, and diaphragms). The maintenance often involves:

• Checking and replacing worn-out gears, pistons, or diaphragms that endure constant physical stress.
• Ensuring that valves and seals are intact to prevent leaks, which can be a common issue due to the high pressures at which these pumps operate.
• Lubrication and adjustment to manage the effects of high viscosity fluids, which can increase mechanical resistance and wear.

In terms of efficiency, positive displacement pumps are superior in applications involving high-viscosity fluids or where precise volumetric flow management is necessary. They maintain high efficiency notwithstanding fluid viscosity or system pressure variations, although their overall energy consumption might be higher due to the mechanical work involved in moving viscous fluids.

The following

Choosing the right pump based on these maintenance and efficiency considerations can significantly impact the operational cost and reliability of fluid handling systems. Properly maintained pumps not only last longer but also operate at their optimal efficiency, thus conserving energy and reducing the overall operational expenses.